Murder From The Shadows - Stab, Kentucky

In this episode, the hosts recount the twisted tale of Sheriff Sam Catron from Pulaski County, Kentucky, who was murdered while attending a fish fry in 2002. Sam, known for his commitment to law enforcement and efforts to combat drug trafficking, is shot in the head by a sniper, prompting a frantic chase of the alleged killer, Danny Shelley, who is linked to local drug dealer Kenneth 'Fingers' White. The investigation reveals a conspiracy involving White, Shelley, and sheriff candidate Jeff Morris, who had ties to the drug trade and was suspected of wanting to eliminate Catron to secure votes. Throughout the episode, local reactions highlight the impact of Catron's death on a small community. The episode details the subsequent investigations, trials, and ultimate convictions of those involved, including Shelley and White, who are sentenced to life in prison without parole. Morris takes a plea deal after initially trying to distance himself from the conspiracy. The narrative intertwines themes of local politics, drug culture, and the tragic consequences of violence in small towns.