The Charming Susan Strangler - Demarest, New Jersey

In this episode, the hosts discuss the unsettling murders of two women, both named Susan, in Demarest, New Jersey. The first victim is Susan Reeve, who disappeared on October 14, 1975, after getting off a bus on her way home. She was later found brutally murdered, leading to an investigation that soon connected her case to that of another woman, Susan Haynes, who vanished around the same time.

The focus of the investigation leads to Robert Relden, a previously imprisoned sex offender known for his charm and manipulation. Despite a history of violent crimes against women, including rape, he uses his good looks and personality to cast doubt in the minds of authorities. Throughout the episode, Relden’s life is examined, revealing his troubled upbringing and the numerous violent crimes he committed.

As investigations proceed, evidence surfaces linking Relden to the Susan murders, including hair samples found in his vehicle and the use of pantyhose as ligatures around the victims' necks. Despite strong evidence, justice is delayed multiple times due to legal maneuvers and courtroom technicalities, including a hung jury.

Ultimately, after enduring a series of trials and legal challenges, including an astonishing escape attempt, Relden is eventually convicted for both murders. The episode culminates with the chilling account of how Relden continues to manipulate the legal system and his attempts to seek parole, despite being a clear danger to society.