21: Aarone Thompson

The podcast episode delves into the heartbreaking story of Erin Thompson, a six-year-old girl last seen in 2005 after a minor argument at home. It details her troubled upbringing in a family characterized by instability and violence, compounded by neglect. Following her disappearance, initial investigations were met with suspicious behavior from her father, Aaron Thompson, and his partner, Shelley Lowe. Despite a massive search for Erin, it was revealed that she had likely died from abuse many months prior to being reported missing.

The episode examines the dynamics within Erin's family, highlighting signs of abuse that permeated their household. Evidence and testimony gradually surfaced implicating Thompson and Lowe in Erin’s tragic fate, particularly after the couple faced scrutiny that led to the removal of their children from their custody. The police received critical information from various sources, leading to revelations about Erin's death and concealment of her body.

In 2007, Aaron Thompson was indicted on numerous charges, including the most serious charge of child abuse resulting in death. The trial revealed horrific tales of beatings and neglect that Erin and her siblings endured. Ultimately, Thompson was convicted and sentenced to 100 years in prison, though he has not revealed the location of Erin's remains. The episode concludes with a reflection on what might have been for Erin, highlighting the tragic loss of a life cut short due to severe abuse and neglect.