26: Reachelle Smith

In this episode, the podcast examines the case of Rochelle Smith, who disappeared at the age of three in Minot, North Dakota, on May 17, 2006. The episode introduces Rochelle's family dynamics, noting that her supposed father, Lee Cohen, was not biologically related to her, despite his claims. Following her disappearance, Cohen, who had a history of issues including drug addiction, was found dead from suspected suicide just five days later. With little evidence pointing to Rochelle's whereabouts, the investigation revealed complications in understanding when she was last seen and the circumstances surrounding her disappearance. Police found evidence suggesting possible foul play, mainly blood from Rochelle in a cooler and Cohen's suspicious death, hinting he could have been involved in her disappearance. Various theories emerged regarding Cohen's actions, including the possibility he either harmed Rochelle or sold her. Despite extensive searches and media attention, Rochelle's case remains cold, highlighting the emotional toll on her family and the community searching for closure. The episode underscores the role of forensic genealogy in cold case investigations and reflects on the chilling realities of missing persons cases.