74: Amiah Robertson

This episode recounts the distressing case of Amaya Robertson, an eight-month-old girl who went missing in March 2019 in Mars Hill, Indiana. Amber Robertson, Amaya's mother, reported her daughter missing only after a domestic dispute where she claimed her boyfriend hit her with a car. Alarmingly, it had been a week since Amaya was last seen when Amber finally contacted authorities. The situation escalated, revealing a backdrop of neglect and chaos within Amber's life, including multiple potential fathers for Amaya and a history of homelessness and instability.

Amber's boyfriend, Robert Lyon, is implicated in the case but remains inconsistent in his statements about Amaya's whereabouts. Witness testimonies further complicate the timeline, revealing that Amber had a bruised and neglected daughter who struggled to meet developmental milestones. As the investigation unfolded, conflicting accounts from Amber and various witnesses painted a murky picture of Amaya's final days.

Despite extensive searches and community efforts, no trace of Amaya has been found. The public's response turned negative towards Amber as details of her neglect emerged, including her failure to report Amaya missing sooner. Prosecutors have charged both Amber and Lyon with felony neglect, arguing their actions led to the severe injury or death of Amaya. Calls for implementing a new law mandating timely reporting of a child's disappearance have also surfaced, reflecting a broader desire for accountability in child welfare cases. The episode concludes with updates on the ongoing legal proceedings against Amber and Lyon and a deep longing for justice for Amaya.