What If... the Super League had happened?

In this episode of The Athletic FC Podcast, the hosts delve into a captivating alternative timeline: what if the European Super League (ESL) had succeeded instead of collapsing in 2021? They begin by outlining the original ESL plan featuring 12 founding clubs, mainly from England, Spain, and Italy, including the big six English clubs. The discussion touches on how the ESL aimed to provide huge financial benefits but faced overwhelming backlash from fans, governments, and football administrators, leading to its rapid demise in just 48 hours.

The hosts consider the implications if the ESL had been allowed to proceed. They speculate on the significant changes to domestic leagues, particularly the Premier League, where the absence of the top six clubs would disrupt competition and revenue streams. The impact on sporting narratives would be profound, potentially reducing the allure of regular matches without a race for Europe and fostering resentment among remaining clubs.

Furthermore, the conversation shifts to the effect on international football, noting that top players from ESL clubs could face bans from international play. This raises questions about player decisions and potential player-led movements against the ESL. The episode concludes by assessing broader trends in football governance and fan loyalty, with an emphasis on the potential for various responses from clubs and leagues worldwide if a disruptive model like the ESL were to take hold again.