45: Colton Clark

The podcast episode recounts the harrowing true story of Colton Clark, who, along with his brother Homer, was placed into the custody of their aunt and uncle in Weewoka, Oklahoma, after being removed from their biological parents due to drug issues. Initially, life on a farm seems like a dream until the brothers face severe physical and emotional abuse over three years. Colton mysteriously goes missing just before a scheduled visit from social services, sparking a frantic search eventually led by Police Chief David Hansen.

Despite extensive efforts, Colton is never found, and suspicions arise concerning the behavior of his caregivers, Rex and Rebecca Clark. Homer eventually escapes from their abusive household and later testifies against his aunt and uncle, revealing the horrific circumstances surrounding Colton's disappearance. The episode details how this case unfolds over the years, leading to the eventual arrest, trial, and conviction of the Clarks for child abuse and the murder of Colton, with Homer, now known as TJ, being a key witness. Despite their conviction, the location of Colton's body remains undisclosed, and TJ vows to find his brother and give him a proper resting place.